Erath Pinot Noir and Pinot Noir Rose

(Feb 15, 2021) A twofer today!  Got two Erath Pinots - one regular, and one Rose.  Erath's a pretty good label and - you know - hometown pride.  I've been to their winery showroom and it is appropriately fancy and beautiful and shit, and they generally do a decent wine.

I'm not MAD at these wines, just a little disappointed.  Like, I paid 50 bucks for a bottle of good Pinot at their place and had no regrets, and enjoyed the HELL out of that wine when some friends came into town.  These are just - they're okay.

The regular Pinot is like 15 bucks for a bottle and that's cheap for a good Oregon Pinot, but the right price for this one.  It's like... it's like...  It's like Frasier.  The TV show with Kelsey Grammer and friends.  You'll have a fine time with it and it's got its moments, but it's ultimately meh.  I suppose some people really like it?  I can't for the life of me remember anything that happened in any of the episodes, though.

I mean, not like a blackout, just like - meh.  It's a big corporate meh of a pinot but sometimes that's okay!  Like when you want to read a book on a wintery afternoon and have a glass of wine that's a little bit sweet and a little bit watery.

That's the thing I don't like about pinots - they have this watery taste in the mouth that just feels like I'm not getting that Wine-with-a-W experience.  You know?  Maybe that's just me.

There's a plasticy flavor the next day too - I mean, I think it was there before, but the other flavors mellow over a day and leave some gnarly ones.

Wow - I'm not really selling this, am I?  I've bought a bunch of Erath Pinot so it's certainly drinkable.  I doubt there will be any wines on this blog that I've bought more bottles of than this one.  It's serviceable, and when people who know a little bit about wines come visit I get this because they expect an Oregon Pinot and this one is that thing.  And it's fine.  It stays in the background during dinner.  Serve it with - I dunno - salmon and huckleberry pie so errything seems local and shit.  This is a serviceable, work-a-day wine that Gets It Done.


The Pinot Noir Rose is a Rose.  If you want to be trendy from two years ago or drink something that's a pink nasty while minimizing the nasty, this is a good choice.  Have it with a lunch salad and a sandwich, or with chocolate ice cream on the couch while you watch Frasier to see if it's actually decent, and how it's aged.  

Imagine a basic Chardonnay - the baseline, generic kind of white wine.  A hint of alcohol, a hint of fruit.  Now up the acidity a bit - not with lemon juice but, like, vitamin-C powder to avoid flavors.  Not much, just a bit.  Make sure there's no tannins or oakyness.  Add three drops of red food coloring.  That's pretty close to this wine!


Again, I'm not really selling it I don't think.  It's fine.  Either of these wines are fine.  They're good for light conversations and light meals with friends.

The Rose had a little of that sparkliness that whites and whitesish wines get the next day.  I like that, personally, but I also like Lima beans so my taste buds are a bit suspect in their desires.

And let's end on the thought that your Wine Snob Friend might be a little suspect in his desires.

Comments